How to Find the Right Social Media Agency for My Business
- Sadie Patton
- 2 days ago
- 4 min read
Most advice about hiring a social media agency tells you to look at their portfolio and read their reviews.
A portfolio proves they can make things that look nice, which you already assumed, because you wouldn't be talking to them if their work looked bad. Reviews prove other people were pleased enough to say so. Neither one tells you whether this will work for your business, and that's the only question you're actually trying to answer.
The reason hiring goes sideways is almost never that the work was ugly. It's that six months in, the posts look fine, the reports say engagement is up, and your phone rings exactly as much as it did before.
So, here's the full framework to find the right social media agency for your business, so it actually works for you.
Before you talk to anyone
Write down what "working" looks like in one sentence.
Not "more followers" or "a better presence."
Something you'd notice in your business like " 3 more inquiries a month".
This takes ten minutes and it changes every conversation that follows, because if you can't finish that sentence, your social media manager will be posting into the void and getting nothing for you.
The five questions to ask
1. If I do nothing, does anything get posted?
If the answer is no, you're buying hands. They'll execute beautifully, but you'll still be the one deciding everything. That's a real service and it's fine, as long as you know that's what you bought.
If the answer is yes, ask the follow-up: how do you decide? The answer tells you whether there's a system behind it or a vibe.
2. Who owns the accounts if I leave?
Nobody asks this and it's the one that can actually hurt you.
Some agencies run your ad account and sometimes your pages under their own business manager. It's convenient right up until you want to leave, and then your audiences, your campaign history, your tracking data, and occasionally your own Facebook page turn out to live somewhere you can't reach. Getting it back ranges from annoying to impossible.
You want a yes without a pause in front of it. Access is something YOU grant THEM.
3. What's not included?
"We'll manage your social media" is not a deliverable, but it's a great starter.
Before starting you need the number of posts, which platforms, who writes the captions, who takes or sources the photos, whether video is in scope, how many revisions, what community management covers, what the reporting includes and how often. If it isn't written down, it isn't included, and you'll find out which parts cost extra after you've signed.
4. If this isn't working in three months, what happens?
A good answer sounds like a process: "Here's what we look at, here's the mark where we'd expect to see it, here's what we change, here's what that conversation looks like".
A bad answer pivots to their methodology, or reminds you what the contract says, or explains that social media takes time. Social media does take time, which is exactly why someone good has already thought about what they'd do when it isn't working yet.
While you're there, ask about the term. Three months with a renewal option is fair. A twelve-month lock with no performance review and a penalty for leaving protects them (and you're the one paying for that protection).
5. Who's actually doing the work?
At larger agencies, the person who sells the account is not usually the person who runs it. The work goes to a junior, or gets outsourced to a company you'll never be introduced to.
Ask who touches your account, and ask how many other clients that person carries. Agency managers commonly run somewhere between three and eight accounts at once, switching between brand voices all day.
The fast red flags
They guarantee a follower number (NOBODY can promise that).
They send a polished proposal within a day of meeting you, before they've asked anything about your business.
Their reporting is follower count and screenshots.
They ran your ads through their account and got weird when you asked about ownership.
Their own presence has been quiet since last spring.
When an agency is the right call
Some of you should hire one, so let me be clear about who.
If you need multiple platforms running at once, paid ads managed alongside organic, real video production, and someone available when something catches fire, that's a team's worth of work and you want a team. That's roughly $2,000 to $6,000 a month, and it's the correct spend for that scope.
If your business is one owner, one or two platforms, and a phone that should ring more, a freelancer or small studio will fit that much better.
How I'd answer the five
If you go quiet, does anything get posted? Yes. I decide from the strategy we set at the start, and I'll tell you what I'm deciding and why.
Who owns the accounts? You do, always, on every platform. I get access to post, but the accounts are yours.
What's not included? Written down before you pay anything. If you want something outside it, I'll quote it if you need it, or I'll tell you that you don't.
If it's not working in three months? We look at saves, inquiries, and what people are actually asking you, and we change the strategy.
Who does the work? Me. You get one person who knows your business, and you stay in control while I get things handled.
Recap
Decide what "working" means in one sentence before you talk to anyone.
If nothing gets posted when you go quiet, you bought hands.
Get account ownership in writing. This is the one that can genuinely cost you.
"Manage your social media" is not a scope.
Ask what happens at three months if it isn't working.
Ask who does the work and how many other clients they carry.
If you want to run these five at me, that's what a first conversation is for, and you're welcome to hold me to my own answers. Start here.
Comments